To Kill Tree or Not To Kill Tree? That is the Christmas Question.


by Anthonism

Exploring the pros and cons of the real vs artificial Christmas tree debate

For those concerned with being "green," this debate may have grabbed your attention every year during the holiday season. According to two separate Comparative Life Cycle Assessments, PE Americas (pdf) and ellipsos (pdf), for the most part, at least within the criterion for the studies performed, there is no debate because choosing either tree has a negligible impact on the environment.

In part, ellipsos concludes, "Consumers who wish to celebrate the holidays with a Christmas tree should do so knowing that the overall environmental impacts of both natural and artificial trees are extremely small when compared to other daily activities such as driving a car. Neither natural nor artificial Christmas tree purchases constitute a significant environmental impact within most American lifestyles."

Given the fact that when an artificial tree made of non biodegradeable PVC ends up in a landfill for eternity, this is a hard pill to swallow. The truth of the matter is, one must look at the complete picture before drawing their own conlusion and each option has some hefty drawbacks. Many factors contribute to which tree, real or fake, is the smart choice when it comes to perserving the environment.

So, after exploring both sides of this Christmas coin, what not-so-eco-friendly tree will Santa be placing your household's gifts under next year?

###

Real vs. Artificial Christmas Trees

by Lori Brown for Earth911.com

The real versus artificial Christmas tree debate replays itself year after year. But the truth is, each option has its own place on the naughty-and-nice list.

Just a few short decades ago, displaying a Christmas tree in your living room really only yielded one option: a real pine or fir tree. That all changed when a U.S.-based toilet bowl brush manufacturer, the Addis Brush Company, created an artificial tree from brush bristles in the 1930s, acting as the prototype for modern artificial trees.

The Pros and Cons of Artificial

Guilt. Many have made it the sole reason to invest in an artificial tree. The thought of cutting down a new tree each year can put a damper on the holidays for some.

Also, cost, convenience and environmental impact are other reasons consumers opt for an artificial tree.

Given the current economic climate, artificial trees may be especially appealing for their investment value when compared with the recurrent, annual expense of a real Christmas tree. Their convenience is also appealing to consumers as they don’t need watering, don’t leave pine needles all over the floor and transportation from tree farm to home isn’t an issue.

But many experts believe artificial trees actually have a greater negative environmental impact when all aspects of an their life cycle are considered.

Today’s artificial trees are typically manufactured with metal and polyvinyl chloride (PVC), a non-biodegradable, petroleum-derived plastic. In addition, many older varieties may contain lead, used as a stabilizer in the manufacturing process.

Despite their PVC contents, artificial trees are non-recyclable and non-biodegradable, meaning they will sit in a landfill for centuries after disposal.

Furthermore, approximately 85 percent of artificial trees sold in the U.S. are imported from China, according to the National Christmas Tree Association (NCTA), adding to their overall environmental footprint.

The Pros and Cons of Real

Approximately 33 million real Christmas trees are sold in North America each year, according to the U.S. EPA. Luckily, about 93 percent of those trees are recycled through more than 4,000 available recycling programs.

Also known as “treecycling,” the act of recycling a Christmas tree is a leading reason many experts agree they are more environmentally friendly than their plastic counterparts.

Treecycling is an easy way to return a renewable and natural source back to the environment instead of disposing it in a landfill, where decomposition rates are slowed due to lack of oxygen.

Christmas trees are recycled into mulch and used in landscaping and gardening or chipped and used for playground material, hiking trails, paths and walkways. They can be used for beachfront erosion prevention, lake and river shoreline stabilization and fish and wildlife habitat.

A single farmed tree absorbs more than 1 ton of CO2 throughout its lifetime. With more than 350 million real Christmas tress growing in U.S. tree farms alone, you can imagine the yearly amount of carbon sequestering associated with the trees. Additionally, each acre of trees produces enough oxygen for the daily needs of 18 people.

In order to ensure a healthy supply of Christmas trees each year, growers must use sustainable farming techniques. For each tree harvested, one to three seedlings are planted the following spring, ensuring a healthy supply of trees.

In order to ensure a healthy supply of Christmas trees each year, growers must use sustainable farming techniques. For each tree harvested, one to three seedlings are planted the following spring, ensuring a healthy supply of trees.

Besides the aforementioned cons associated with real Christmas trees, they are farmed as agricultural products, meaning repeated applications of pesticides, herbicides and fertilizers may be used throughout their lifetime. The ideal tree would be raised organically, using integrated pest management techniques rather than chemicals.

Another con associated with real Christmas trees may depend on where you live. For climates where coniferous trees don’t grow, that tree in your living room may have had to travel hundreds of miles to reach the lot, significantly impacting the environmental impact associated with travel. However, a tree trucked from a couple states away is still traveling thousands of miles less than one from overseas.

An Even Better Option

Go one step further than the real versus artificial debate and consider a living, potted tree this Christmas. Though not feasible for everybody due to climate and land availability, living trees are brought into the home for about 10 days, then replanted after Christmas. If you don’t have the land for replanting, your local parks department will likely accept your tree for planting after the holidays.

The Verdict?

So what’s the final word? Drumroll please… Real trees top our charts for holiday adornment. Even though they might shed needles on your floor, the investment in a U.S.-based product, the carbon-neutral nature of their production and their ease of recycling make them a clear winner.

###

Comprehensive Comparison Chart

Regarding the use of real or artificial Christmas trees, this table compares these eco-friendly factors; place of origin, method of production, components, PVC free, lead free, carbon neutral, chemicals, disposal, renemable resource, and eco-friendly.

Originally provided by the National Christmas Tree Association

###

Vote on Stupid Ignorant Asshole polls in

Holidays and Nature

The Life of a Christmas Tree

#anthonism #etiquetteed #debate #holidays #nature

Recent Evidence
Recent Etiquette Ed
Posts Are Coming Soon
Stay tuned...
Shop
You're Like Everyone Else, Different

You're Like Everyone Else, Different

Anthonism's quote, "You Are Just Like Everyone Else, Different." T-shirts available in many styles and colors. $30.95 (Zazzle usually has 15% off promos)

'Mind Your Manners!' Citation

'Mind Your Manners!' Citation

Fake Citation: You are hereby cited for violating social norms, disobeying codes of conduct, and committing acts of rudeness $7.00 + S/H

'My Mind Keeps Fcuknig With My Head'

'My Mind Keeps Fcuknig With My Head'

What's wrong with your thinking cap? Well, putting whether or not you're thinking straight aside, the brain is built to play tricks on you and this witty t-shirt design demonstrates one of the many mind numbing ways it does so. $35.95 (Zazzle usually has 15% off promos) In our Zazzle Store

The Network
Warning Label Mind Your Manners Rudeness reduction program is in full force
Featured Poll
  • Facebook App Icon
  • Twitter App Icon
  • Google+ App Icon
  • YouTube Classic
  • Instagram App Icon
  • Pinterest App Icon
  • RSS App Icon
Man's Marbles RSS Feed
  • w-facebook
  • Twitter Clean
  • Google+ Clean
  • YouTube - White Circle
  • Instagram Clean
  • Pinterest Clean
  • RSS Clean

© 2013-2018 Land of Lombardia, LLC